My own shelves could boast recent biographies of Augustus (A.H.M. Jones), Tiberius, Claudius (both by Barbara Levick), Caligula (Anthony Barrett), Nero (two, by B.H. Warmington and Miriam Griffin), Titus (Brian Jones), Hadrian (Stewart Perowne), and Marcus Aurelius (A.R. Birley).
The 1990s filled the gaps with Levick’s Vespasian, Jones’ The Emperor Domitian, Bennett’s Trajan: Optimus Princeps, and Birley’s excellent Hadrian the Restless Emperor. But no Antoninus Pius.
I balked at the task, being then immersed in other things, as I believed that it would entail, at the very least, a thorough revision of Willy Hüttl’s massive Römische Reichsbeamte und Offiziere unter Antoninus Pius (Prague 1933), with its exhaustive catalogue of office-bearers during the period AD 138–161. And time wore on.
But the gap has now been filled, so to speak, by retired teacher and Labour councillor John McHugh, a self-professed ancient history enthusiast, who has written The Reign of Emperor Antoninus Pius, AD 138–161.
But is it any good?
First impressions
We don’t get off to a good start on page 1 with the passage of Ausonius quoted as an epigraph to Chapter 1. This fourth-century poet (here lifted from Hugh Evelyn-White’s 1919 Loeb translation — shouldn’t he be credited?) is a bold choice in a book about a second-century emperor, but a typo in the second line (“mild reign” for “mid-reign”, Evelyn-White’s translation of mediis) doesn’t help; nor does the mistaken attribution (“Book XIV” for stanza XV — four lines of verse hardly make a “book”). Of course, few readers will notice. The publisher’s proof-reader certainly didn’t.Mr McHugh is keen to use Latin terms wherever possible, but often comes to grief. The bridge linking Hadrian’s sepulchre with the Campus Martius, for example, was the Pons Aelius (not Aelia, bridges being masculine); the military treasury was known as the aerarium militare (not aerium, “airy”) and the system of welfare for children was known as the alimenta (not alimentia); Hadrian’s nickname for the young Marcus Aurelius was Verissimus (not “Verrissimus”, which isn’t Latin); and the plural of delator (“denouncer”) is delatores, not (as frequently here) “delators”. Nor was Marcus Aurelius’ philosophical work entitled “Mediations”, but this one is surely a typo. Surely?
Oddly, Mr McHugh leaves the word pilicrepus (literally, “ball-rattler”, the term for a participant in a ball game) untranslated in his version of CIL VI, 9797 (pictured here), which he has lifted (uncredited) from Edward Champlin’s 1985 article about this inscription.
Even Roman names can baffle Mr McHugh. Hadrian’s mother-in-law’s name was Matidia, not the Germanic-rooted “Matilda”. And he even mangles Pius’ own name on its first outing (p. xxiii, where “Boionus” should be Boionius)!
Confusing narrative
For readers who manage to battle through Chapter 1, with its avalanche of names (few of them strictly necessary in a book about Antoninus Pius), the bad news is that there is more of the same. Amid the deluge of barely relevant information, Mr McHugh skates over Pius’ marriage to the wealthy patrician Faustina, which he places “between AD 102 and 110”. Why, we are never told. Hüttl suggested AD 110, when Pius would have been 24 years of age, a sensible suggestion, whereas AD 102, eight years earlier, surely demands some special pleading.
Mr McHugh confidently places Pius’ governorship of Asia in “spring AD 135–136”, although the gap in the lists spans AD 133–137. In fact, it is a conjecture of Werner Eck that places the governorship in 135/6 (summer to summer), in order to fit the similarly undated Quintus Gargilius Antiquus before him and Quintus Pomponius Marcellus after him.
Mr McHugh often repeats himself, as when we are told (p. 60) about the “Domus Tiberiana, which is where Antoninus made his home”, only to read a little later (p. 61) that, instead of using the palace on the Palatine, “he used the Domus Tiberiana”, and that his private banquets (p. 64) were “probably held in the Domus Tiberiana”.
More serious, however, is the fact that his research is occasionally outdated, and sometimes woefully so. For example, he still believes in a Brigantian Revolt in AD 154, handily dismissed by Nick Hodgson in 1995, and his judgement of the work of Aurelius Victor as “brief moralizing summaries of the emperors” (even if that had ever been justified) is comprehensively disproven by a decade of publications by Justin Stover.
Nor is his prose always as clear as it could be. For example, the Augustan History records that Pius “was raised at Lorium on the Aurelian Way, where afterward he built the palace whose ruins stand there today”. Mr McHugh claims rather cryptically that “excavations at Castel Di Guido have possibly revealed parts of the villa”. Readers may wonder if it was something else that was uncovered. But in fact, there is no question that an elegant villa has been found at Castel di Guido on the via Aurelia. It is simply its identification as the Antonine palace, and even as ancient Lorium, that has yet to be confirmed.
Where’s the evidence?
Sometimes Mr McHugh’s “explanation” of events is rather convoluted (such as his discussion of the succession crisis of 136/8), while his judgement cannot always be trusted and his sources are not always cited. For example, he is very keen to promote the idea that Lucius Verus was always Hadrian’s first choice of heir, despite the fact that Cassius Dio explicitly says that he favoured Marcus. He also states categorically that Acilius Glabrio was “selected to become the governor of Africa from April AD 138 for a year”. But Glabrio’s tenure is usually placed in AD 139.
For some reason, Mr McHugh’s “quotations” of ancient sources (always in unacknowledged translation) often seem quaint and dated. For example, in Hadrian’s well-known animula vagula poem, comes corporis is rendered as “comrade of this my clay” (it literally means “companion of my body”), while a quotation from Xiphilinus’ epitome of Cassius Dio includes the curiously baffling word “cumminsplitter” (the Greek word is κυμινοπρίστης, kuminopristês, literally “splitter of cumin seeds”, an idiom suggesting a frugal or parsimonious lifestyle). Couldn’t we simply have had “skinflint”?
Coinage questions: getting technical
A dozen coins are illustrated in the plates, but readers may wonder at some of the dates that Mr McHugh has attached to them. How can the REX ARMENIIS DATVS coin (plate 4) be “c. AD 141–143” while the REX QVADIS DATVS coin (plate 3) is “c. AD 140–143”? The answer is that it cannot. Both coins are dated (just like the one in plate 7) by Pius’ title of COS III, which lasted from AD 140 until the end of 144. (Note that these timespans are not approximate, as Mr McHugh implies with his “circa”. The coin in plate 8 is firmly dated to AD 159, not “c. AD 159”, by Pius’ TRP XXII title.)
The next coin is the well-known BRITANNIA COS IIII issue (plate 6), which Mr McHugh dates to “c. AD 154/155”, but the clear statement of TR P XVIII on the obverse dates it precisely to AD 155 (definitely no “circa” required). Incidentally, the dating of “AD 154–155” for this coin found in the venerable Roman Imperial Coinage Vol. 3 (p. 142, no. 930) reflects Harold Mattingly’s eccentric belief that Pius’ tribunician power ran from 25 February, rather than the standard 10 December. Admittedly, it is possible that this coin was struck in late December AD 154, but no earlier — as shorthand, AD 155 would not be inaccurate.
Similarly, Mr McHugh states that the coin depicting the goddess Annona (plate 32) was “minted between AD 145 and 161”, presumably because it mentions Pius’ fourth consulship. But the reverse legend reads TR POT XIX COS IIII, dating the coin precisely to AD 156. (The caption erroneously reads “RIC no. 25”, which should be RIC Vol. 3 p. 56, no. 250.)
Readers may wonder why the Liberalitas coin (plate 31) is dated to AD 145, since there is nothing obviously indicating this in the photo. In fact, the coin legend is not ANTONINUS PIUS LIBERALITAS, as Mr McHugh says, but LIBERALITAS AVG IIII COS IIII (“the emperor’s generosity for the fourth time with the fourth consulship”). Although Pius’ title of COS IIII lasted from AD 145 until his death in AD 161, he is thought to have made a fourth distribution of cash to the populace in AD 145, marking either the coming-of-age of Lucius Verus or more probably the marriage of Marcus Aurelius and Faustina the younger. It certainly occurred prior to AD 148, when he made his fifth distribution of cash.
Readers may also wonder why Mr McHugh has dated the gold aureus in plate 34 to AD 145. This is another coin dated only by Pius’ title of COS IIII, but Mr McHugh would like to connect it with the dedication of the Temple of Venus and Roma some years earlier, because it depicts the goddess Roma. (Why not also Venus? Or a temple?) And if the coin commemorated the 900th anniversary of Rome in AD 148, and Pius’ own decennalia in the same year — which is Mr McHugh’s alternative suggestion —, why does he think that it was issued three years earlier?
Odds and ends
Map 1 shows “Römisches Reich im Jahr 125 AD” (why a German map? and why not of Antonine date?). Map 2 (“Roman Forts on the Antonine Wall”) shows the seven known fortlets (Kinneil, Watling Lodge, Seabegs, Glasgow Bridge, Wilderness Plantation, Summerston, Cleddans) as if they were forts, and includes Camelon and Bishopton, which are not on the Antonine Wall. (Old Kilpatrick has been mis-spelled.) Map 3 (“Ancient Rome”) is in Latin (from an uncredited German atlas), which is fair enough, but readers may struggle to locate places mentioned in the text. Plate 26 purports to show “the vallum of the Antonine Wall at Rough Castle”, but actually depicts the ditch (which Romans would have called the fossa, since vallum is a rampart).The book is equipped with 28 pages of endnotes, for which the reader is afforded none of the usual aids in keying them with the text; we expect at least a running header, flagging up which page of notes relates to which chapter. But this is the least of the note-related irritations. Mr McHugh has adopted a tediously verbose method of citation. Take note 44 at the top of page 187: “Birpey, Anthony R., Hadrian. The Restless Emperor, pp. 281, 353 n. 8; Macie, David, Historia Augusta, Volume 1, p. 46 n. 2; Syme, Ronald, ‘Guard Prefects of Trajan and Hadrian’, The Journal of Roman Studies, Vol. 70 (1980), pp. 64—80.” All of these works have previously been cited, and will be again, in similarly fulsome fashion (though Birley’s and Magie’s surnames are usually correctly spelled). They are also in the bibliography, which means that a considerably more succinct method of citation could have been used each time. (And it should be mentioned that, on page 46 of Magie’s Loeb volume (referenced here), there are two note 2s. I wonder which one was intended.)
All in all, this is a disappointing culmination to a forty-year wait for a biography of Antoninus Pius. I would rather recommend Bernard Rémy’s Antonin le Pieux vu par les textes antiques (Paris 2012), which is missing from Mr McHugh’s bibliography.

























